Hamilton Halton Construction Association   Ontario Architecture  
Mohawk College Building and Construction
home
Contact Building Terms Building Styles Building Terms

Building Styles

Gothic Revival (1750 - 1900)

Origins --- --- Gothic Revival Architecture

Gothic in Europe------Kings College Cambridge___Gothic Revival Abbey

Eastern Ontario --- Picton--- Medoc--- Ottawa

Central Ontario--- Simcoe---- Dundas-- Bolton-- Paris--- Progeston--- Cobourg
---- Jordan----- Vaughan --- Port Hope--- Guelph--- Elora

Western Ontario ---- Stratford--- London---

Northern Ontario --- Perkinsfield--- Sault Ste. Marie--- ----

__

Origins

Since a great many of the early settlers in Ontario were from the United Kingdom, it is not surprising that their buildings often contain details found in English Gothic and medieval architecture. Many elements of stone buildings in England are translated into wood on cottages and smaller residences in Ontario Gothic Revival buildings. The overall effect is eclectic and usually ornate. The Gothic Cottage is probably the most pervasive Ontario residential style prior to 1950.

Gothic Revival Architecture

Not to be confused with Neo-Gothic, which is a twentieth century adaptation to large institutional buildings, the Gothic Revival is a direct translation of medieval details and building practices to the Ontario climate. Sometimes a Georgian frame is fitted with a variety of Gothic or Tudor details such as vergeboarding, finials, scalloping, lancet windows, hood molds, and carved label stops. Other times, specifically the churches, the layout is asymmetrical and picturesque as well.

Gothic Revival in Europe

for more examples of European Classical and Gothic revivals see http://www.ontarioarchitecture.com/Classrevivals.htm

Gothic Revival in Europe was a reaction to the Classical Revival that had taken hold over the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries. Proponents of the Gothic Revival saw the movement not simply in structural terms, but in religious or spiritual terms as well. The movement was lead by John Ruskin and Augustus Pugin.

The adherents of the Gothic Revival held the view that religions had produced their own supreme architectural forms that best expressed their ethos and spirit. Thus Renaissance architecture, which sought its inspiration from the "heathen" temples of Rome, was dismissed as pagan. Only Gothic represented the full flowering of the Christian faith.

King's College Cambridge

Gothic architecture was developed at a time when England and France were often ruled under the same crown. It was a style that developed simultaneously in Britain and northern Europe. This detail from King's College Cambridge shows the delicate tracery, multiple muntin bars and ogee curves distinctive of the style.

The Gothic style is also related to the many monasteries throughout Britain, closed by Henry VIII, but still with the legacy of learning, education and secluded cloistered existence.

Kings College Cambrige

Abbey

The Gothic Revival in England was not simply a revival of a method of working, but more a revival of all things indigenous to Britain. Ruskin, Pugin, and the others who backed the revival of the Gothic style were revolting against the mechanization of the industrial revolution. Their ideas ultimately led to the Arts and Crafts movement

 

Pugin Church

Eastern Ontario: Upper Saint Lawrence and Quinte

The war of 1812 left many of the farmsteads along the the banks of the Saint Lawrence in ruins. The Georgian style buildings were mostly rebuilt in the Neo-Classical style, but the new buildings created

by both homesteaders and new immigrants from Europe were often in the Gothic style, particularly in Kingston and the Bay of Quinte,

Picton

Another name for Gothic Revival is Jigsaw Gothic for obvious reasons. The intricate vergeboarding, complete with crockets, kingposts, finials, and quatrefoils is really breathtaking.

This lovely home, now an Inn, emphasizes the verticality of the Gothic Revival. The second and third storey windows are remarkably tall and slender.

Gothic Revival in Picton

Picton Ontario

St. Mary Magdalene, Picton, 1834

Also in Woodstock is the City Hall made in 19**.

The stones are large and rusticated with large quoins. The paired round-headed arches on the upper level are very similar to those in Byzantine buildings of the 5th and 6th centuries. These were followed by the Romanesque paired arches found in Pisa and other parts of Europe, even as far north as England as seen in Winchester.

 

 

 

Picturesque

Picton Ontario

Picton

Here is another great example of Regency or Picturesque Gothic. The brick is made in a variety of colours that reflect the local clay mixture.

 

Gothic Revival church

Bolton Ontario

Medoc

There is a mixture of styles on this house. The core and the vergeboarding are Gothic, but the bay window, complete with segmental arches and iron cresting, is more Second Empire.

Both gables have lancet windows and are beautifully constructed with large voussoirs. The front door is also beautifully constructed and well maintained.

Gothic Revival

Medoc Ontario

Ottawa

The Parliament Buildings in Ottawa, constructed in the last decades of the 19th century, reflect the public buildings in London England and illustrate some of the features praised by John Ruskin, the foremost architectural critic of the time. The architect was allowed great liberty in the design which is a mixture of the following: Gothic, lancet arches, trefoils, tracery, Baroque, iron cresting, and Château, steeply pitched roofs, and dormers.

Notice that the voussoirs atop the windows are in a different colour from the other stone of the building giving a dichromatic effect, an element that was, again, admired by Ruskin. The windows themselves have a trefoil pattern that is repeated regardless of the arc of the window. The roof is patinated copper that looks very handsome with the red window detailing.

Gothic Revival Civic Building

Ottawa Ontario

Central Ontario

European settlers from both Britain and Germany made many beautiful buildings in the Gothic style. The Canada Farmer periodical published plans and

 

elevations for the farmhouse which became the Gothic Revival Cottage, the single most popular home style in Canada until 1950.

Simcoe

A drive through rural Ontario is likely to provide many examples of the small Gothic Revival Cottages in a variety of vernacular materials. The basic design was promoted in the 19th century by academics J.C. Loudon and A.J. Downing as well as the Canadian Farmer (1865) where it is featured complete with construction drawings for the farmer to build.

Details such as the finials, bargeboarding, and window hoods add the Gothic flavor. The scalloping under the eaves is also medieval. The door detailing, in this example, is Georgian.

Gothic Revival Cottage

Simcoe Ontario

Gothic Revival Cottage

The Gothic Revival Cottage was the most prevalent residential design in all of Ontario prior to the 1950s. Generally speaking, the GRC belonged to the farmer who owned the land, the design for the cottage was written up in Canadian Farmer magazine in 1865. This cottage has a segmental arch in the window within the gable. It is finished in local limestone, but not with the same finish as the more stately manors in the escarpment. This limestone is in irregular pieces and has been re-pointed many times prior over the years.

Doctor's Office Dundas

The Doctor's Office is board and batten with wonderful molding.

Over the top widow is a drip mould. There are lancet arches, curved four-centered arches, and wonderful sills. The building has been beautifully restored.

Paris

Regency Gothic

The Paris Plains Church located on a beautiful plain just outside Paris, was called the West Dumfries Wesleyan Chapel when it was built in 1845. The Chapel itself is a basic vernacular box shape, the building was an auditory hall large enough for one preacher and a small congregation. The design of these towerless box churches was to be seen in the window and door details. This chapel is a wonderful mix of 19th century styles.

From a distance it looks like a Gothic Revival Church simply because of the lancet windows. The overall size and shape of the building, however, is not. The roof pitch is low, there is no bell tower, and no other gothic detailing, not even drip moulds. Because of this it is called Regency Gothic.

The cobblestone exterior finish is unique to the Paris area being "imported" by Levi Broughton from New York in 1838. The stonework on this chapel is particularly impressive considering that it was all done by volunteers from the congregation.

The elegant, interlacing muntin bars on the lunette and windows became popular during the Regency period and became extremely popular as can be seen on the Bolton Chapel below. The original door was replaced by a well- meaning Italianate improver some years later.

 

 

Gothic Revival Church

Paris Ontario

Bolton

Fieldstone was a more usual medium for country churches, and these generally illustrate exceptional trade skill as well as tasteful design. Box-shaped country chapels served the spiritual and social needs of the surrounding community for many years until advanced transportation made access to towns more available.

The shutters are shaped to fit the lancet windows and may have been closed during storms to protect the multi-paned windows. These wide lancets were introduced during the Regency period.Corner buttressing is discreet and understated to match the tower.

Gothic Revival church

Bolton Ontario

Progeston

This house has far fewer Gothic elements than that above, but it has very steeply pitched gables, gingerbread or vergeboarding, and the board and batten finish that was popular during the era. Board and batten was originally used in Gothic Revival ecclesiastical architecture - see Carpenter's Gothic - but it was also used on other structures.

The gable windows have half-rounded arches, while the first floor bays have segmental arches, showing an Italianate influence.

Gothic Revival Cottage

Progeston Ontario

Cobourg

St. Peter's Church in Cobourg was one of the earliest Anglican parish churches in Upper Canada. The original frame church was replaced in many stages by this brick Gothic Revival structure. The tower and front façade, shown in this image, were designed by Henry Bowler Lane. They were constructed in 1844.

The church façade is constructed around a central buttressed tower. The façade has lancet windows and doors with hood molds. A central rose window on the tower is accentuated by a horizontal band. The parapets on both the tower and the aisles are castellated.

Gothic Revival Cottage

Cobourg Ontario

Jordan

St, John's Anglican - Episcopal church was built on the Niagara Escarpment in 1841. Like the above, this is a typical rural church made from local stone in the picturesque medieval style. It is symmetrical, with a central processional aisle and straight backed pews.

To distinguish it as a Gothic Revival building, there is battlementing on the tall, slim, tower and diaper-latticed lancet windows. The windows are propotionally quite large for the wall space, letting in a light that floods the small church beautifully.

Gothic Revival church

Jordan Ontario

Vaughan

This Gothic Revival building has been modified into a residence. The second storey balcony was added much later, but the original building is clearly 19th century.

The dichromatic brick patterns are the most outstanding feature of this building. Quoins, bands, blind arches, and a lozenge within the wider gable all point to Gothic Revival. The second storey window was added later, and the roof is new. Quite possibly there were vergeboarding and finials on the original building.

Gothic Revival House

Vaughan Ontario

Port Hope

Here is a rare example of a Gothic Revival residence using red brick instead of stone with white detailing.

The frontispiece has a stepped gable that holds the date. The front porch has a door with a low lancet arch, dripmold, and label stops. Above the porch is a balustraded balcony with twin lancet doors. The two other second storey windows have fractables. The lower floor has square dripmolds and label stops.

The walls are buttressed at the corners, and the side walls have bay windows. There are multiple chimneys on the roof suggesting that there are many fireplaces.

This is a very early and very good example of Gothic Revival in a large, well- situated house.

Period Revival Mansion

Port Hope Ontario

Guelph

Our Lady of the Immaculate Conception in Guelph (1876) was designed by Joseph Connolly in the French Gothic Style or "Style Ogivale" as it is known in France. It has a large rose window, twin towers, and extravagant statuary on the front façade. The tympanum over the front entrance is also carved with religious figures. Guelph is founded on rock, and so is this cathedral.

Our Lady was meant to occupy the same position in Guelph as the medieval cathedrals occupied in France. It was meant as a civic and social center and a national monument as much as a place of worship. Situated at the top of a hill overlooking a long boulevard down to the train station, this building has presence above and beyond that of its intrinsic beauty.

Gothic Revival Church

Guelph Ontario

Elora

Aside from the lancet window and the scalloping, this building shows its Gothic favor through sheer verticality. The board and batten trim accentuates the vertical thrust of the walls. The second storey dormers are also far higher than would be found on equivalents done in one of the Classical based styles (Neoclassical or Beaux Arts Classicism).

The store front windows have very large panes and are probably not original, but the placement of the windows and the trim has been done to match the original.

Gothic Revival House

Elora Ontario

Western Ontario

The three gable Gothic style was prevalent throughout Southern Ontario. The yellow brick produced Western Ontario gives the towns a

 

distinctive style. Red and orange brick was shipped in from the east. Often this was used in dichromatic finishes like the farmhouse in Stratford below.

Stratford

The three gable motif is a regular part of the Gothic Revival repertoire. The vergeboarding on this beautifully restored building is new

 

Gothic Revival Cottage

Stratford Ontario

Stratford

originally the house had king posts with trefoil ornaments. Both gable finishes are effective.

Gothic Revival church

Jordan Ontario

King Post detail

The yellow brick characteristic of Western Ontario is here used to good effect.

Gothic Revival House

Vaughan Ontario

Stratford

Here is a rare example of a Gothic Revival residence using red brick instead of stone with white detailing.

The gable has a rare version of the double lancet window.

 

Period Revival Mansion

Stratford Ontario

London

Trefoisl are used in the dormers to add light to the ceiling of this small church. It is built in the simple country style. Small abutments are found between the lancet windows.

 

Period Revival Mansion

London Ontario

Northern Ontario

Variations on the Gothic are found across the north as settlers arrived both from Europe and from the east. Fur trading was the major reason for travel in

 

the north. Settlers made homesteads along the lake front and river beds.

 

Perkinsfield
Carpenter's Gothic

Carpenters Gothic is a variation of the Gothic style in wood. It is also known as Fretsaw Gothic. Very popular in Lower Canada, new Brunswich and Nova Scotia, it made its way into the French communities of Northern Ontario like Perkinsfield.

 

Gothic Revival Church

Guelph Ontario

Precious Blood
Sault St. Marie

The Gothic revival style continued through the 19th century in church design across Canada largely due to the writings of Ruskin and Pugin. churches are made with local materials but in a traditional European floor plan.

Gothic Revival House

Sault St. Marie Ontario

BLDG10043

Gothic Revival Extra Reading and Films

Books

Blumenson, John. Ontario Architecture A Guide to Styles and Terms. 1978

Cruickshank, Tom, and John de Visser, Old Toronto Houses,Toronto: Firefly Books, 2003.

Cruickshank, Tom, and John de Visser, Old Ontario Houses,Toronto: Firefly Books, 2000.

MacRae, Marion, and Anthony Adamson. The Ancestral Roof: Domestic Architecture of Upper Canada. Toronto: Clarke, Irwin, 1963.

For information on Gothic Revival architecture in specific areas within Ontario there are some very good books listed under the About page.

Films

Becoming Jane - Anne Hathaway

The Madness of King George 1994

"His Majesty was all powerful and all knowing. But he wasn't quite all there."

Persuasion, (1995) (2007)

Pride and Prejudice, (1995) (2005)

Sense and Sensability, (1995) (2008)

 

 

Agraffe Transom reveal Quoins Shutter railing Chimney Keystone Transom Balcony Pediment Sash Shutter Veranda Chimney Transom Shutter Sash Arch Transom Sash Windows Voussoirs Band Flat Arch Door Surround Shutters Chimney Stairs Sash Window Shutters Veranda Sash Quoins Roof sash Transom Shutters Cornice